← All newsroom articles

Immigration Detention

ICE's actions: Is it good or bad for America?

ICE set records in 2026 for arrests and deportations. Supporters call it the law finally being enforced. Critics point to who is being detained, deaths in custody and two U.S. citizens killed in Minneapolis. Here are the facts and both sides.

Inmate Reviews logo

By Inmate Reviews Editorial Desk · · 5 min read

ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations officers during an operation in Dallas
ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations officers during a targeted enforcement operation in Dallas, shown as an illustration. Photo: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Public domain

Few questions divide the country right now like this one. Whether ICE's actions are good or bad for America depends a lot on what you value most and which facts you weigh. Inmate Reviews covers immigration detention because many of our readers have a loved one inside, so we set out the numbers, the strongest case on each side, and what to do if someone you love is detained. You can decide the rest.

The numbers

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is the federal agency that arrests, detains and deports people who are in the country in violation of immigration law. In the fiscal year that ended September 30, 2026, the Department of Homeland Security says ICE:

  • Deported 483,200 people, the most in its history. The previous record was 442,640 the year before, and the total in fiscal 2024 was 271,484.
  • Made more than 491,000 arrests, peaking at 50,925 in August 2026.
  • Held a record number of people. The detained population reached 70,766 on January 24, 2026, the highest in ICE's public data, before falling to about 60,000 by April.

President Trump's stated goal is 1 million removals a year, so even the record falls short of what the administration set out to do.

The case that ICE's actions are good for America

Supporters make several arguments:

  • It's the law. Congress wrote the immigration laws, and supporters say enforcing them, after years of high border crossings, restores the rule of law and fairness to people who immigrated legally.
  • Public safety. The administration says it is focused on dangerous people. ICE figures cited by news reports say about 60% of people in its detention had criminal convictions or pending charges, and ICE budget documents set a goal of deporting 500,000 people with criminal backgrounds in each of the next two years.
  • Results. "Fiscal Year 2026 saw the highest number of ICE deportations and arrests for any year in ICE's history," Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said. Steven Camarota of the Center for Immigration Studies, which favors lower immigration, said, "There is no question the administration has increased enforcement more than any prior president."
  • Public support for the goal. In a Reuters/Ipsos poll in February, 61% of Americans said they support deporting immigrants who are in the country illegally, including 92% of Republicans and 35% of Democrats.

The case that ICE's actions are bad for America

Critics make several arguments too:

  • Who is being detained. An analysis by the libertarian Cato Institute of early fiscal 2026 data found that 73% of people in ICE custody had no criminal conviction and 5% had a violent conviction. The Migration Policy Institute estimated that about 20% of deportations from January 2025 to July 2026 involved someone with a criminal conviction.
  • Deaths in custody. By one researcher's count, 47 people died in ICE custody between January 2025 and mid-April 2026, 16 of them in 2026.
  • Minneapolis. During an enforcement surge in January, an ICE agent fatally shot Renee Nicole Good on January 7, and Customs and Border Protection agents later killed Alex Pretti. Both were U.S. citizens, and both shootings were caught on bystander video. The Justice Department opened a civil rights investigation into Pretti's death, and the administration pulled about 700 agents out of Minnesota.
  • Tactics. Even the president has acknowledged the criticism. Asked on *60 Minutes*, Trump said his policies "might be too tough" and "a lot of people would think it is too tough," while adding that he gets "very high marks for getting the bad ones out."

Why the criminal-record numbers differ. The 60% ICE figure counts people with convictions or pending charges. The 73% Cato figure counts only convictions, so someone charged but not yet convicted lands on different sides of the two figures. Both can be true at once, and the data behind them comes from different points in the year.

What Americans think

The public holds both views at the same time. Most people support the goal of deporting people who are here illegally, and most dislike how it's being done:

  • PBS News/NPR/Marist (January 2026): 65% said ICE has gone too far, up from 54% the June before. 22% said its approach is about right and 12% said it hasn't gone far enough.
  • Reuters/Ipsos (February 2026): 61% support deporting people here illegally, and 60% said immigration agents have gone too far.
  • AP-NORC (July 2026): 29% approved of how ICE is enforcing immigration laws, 49% disapproved and 21% were in between or unsure.

The politics are shifting too. After the midterms, Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.), expected to lead the House Homeland Security Committee, said Democrats will investigate the administration's immigration policies. Some Democrats, like Rep. Henry Cuellar of Texas, say they have urged officials to focus deportations on people with criminal records, while others go further: Minnesota Senator-elect Peggy Flanagan said, "We will rip ICE apart."

So, good or bad?

The honest answer is that it depends on the tradeoff you're weighing. If your top concern is enforcing the law as written and removing people with serious criminal records, the record numbers look like progress. If your top concern is due process, safety in custody and how agents treat people, including U.S. citizens, the same year raises hard questions. Many Americans hold both concerns at once, which is what the polls show.

What is clear is that the stakes are high for the families involved, and that Congress, the courts and voters will keep shaping what ICE does next.

If someone you love is detained by ICE

  • Find them. Use ICE's Online Detainee Locator System. You'll need their name and country of birth, or their A-number.
  • Get legal help early. Immigration court is civil, so there is no right to a free government lawyer. Look for nonprofit legal service providers near the detention center.
  • Don't sign what you don't understand. Detained people may be asked to sign papers agreeing to leave. Talk to a lawyer first if you can.
  • Keep records. Write down dates, names, the facility and any case numbers.

Inmate Reviews will update this article as new data, court rulings or policy changes come out.

Sources

Our articles are written independently of advertisers. Businesses can't pay for coverage, and Preferred listings elsewhere on the site are advertising, not endorsements. This article is general information, not legal advice. See an error? Email corrections to hello@inmatereviews.com.

More from the Newsroom